The Rule of Jenny Pen, a New Zealand film that premiered at Fantastic Fest 2024, delves into the realm of dementia and the horrors of aging. The story unfolds within the confines of the Royal Pine Mews care home, where patients grapple with various stages of dementia and physical rehabilitation. Amidst this setting, one patient stands out for his vicious behavior, terrorizing others while remaining unnoticed by the staff.
The heart of the film lies in the captivating performances of veteran actors Geoffrey Rush and John Lithgow. Rush portrays an arrogant judge named Stefan who experiences a stroke in court, leading him to the care facility where he crosses paths with Lithgow’s character, Dave Crealy. Dave, wielding a plastic doll head named Jenny Pen, unleashes madness on the patients, with Stefan becoming his primary target due to his refusal to succumb to the abuse.
Director James Ashcroft, along with co-writer Eli Kent, creates a disorienting atmosphere through distorted sound effects and unconventional visuals, keeping viewers on edge and questioning reality. While the powerhouse performances of Rush and Lithgow shine, the film falters in weaving together its narrative threads, particularly in exploring Dave’s backstory and the staff’s obliviousness to his actions.
Despite its shortcomings, The Rule of Jenny Pen is a compelling watch, thanks to the stellar acting and the eerie ambiance crafted by the filmmakers. As the film navigates the complexities of dementia and the vulnerability of aging bodies, it prompts viewers to reflect on the unseen struggles within care facilities. Through its exploration of madness and power dynamics, the movie offers a unique perspective on the human psyche and the depths of cruelty that can arise in unexpected places.
