sun was concerned about the discipline of judges.
Supreme court (SC) has compiled data on early termination of powers of judges as disciplinary action for misconduct. One of the most common violations were the red tape in business, their formation and registration, as well as making decisions in hindsight, and even due boundaries. There were cases of the proclamation of unjust decisions and intervention in corporate disputes. Not foreign to the servants of Themis were ordinary “human weakness” in the form of truancy, driving under the influence, fights with the police and peaceful sleep at the workplace right at the time of trial. Several judges were able to make excuses for their violations, or who have been recognized by unintentional mistakes not resulting in serious harm or expired prosecute.
Report of the doings of the servants of Themis was prepared by the disciplinary Board of the armed forces, which studied complaints of those judges who did not agree with the decisions of the regional authorities on early termination of their powers beginning in 2016. In this case the sun, despite the fact that the actions of erring judges belittled the authority of the judiciary, did not mention their names.
So, recognized as legitimate the suspension of the judges of the Birobidzhan district court, which, “having a low level of professional qualifications, were poorly prepared for court proceedings and litigation, admitted red tape in the consideration of cases.” In addition, it was noted his “misbehavior” in the criminal proceedings — however, without specifying details. But the main reason was still the outcome of the judges, who from 2015 to 2017 reviewed 219 criminal cases, but only 37 of them in a General manner. And even if this appellate court overturned 11 convictions, and another 23 changed. Also, a lack of knowledge by the judge of the theory of law, criminal, criminal procedure of the law, “the inability to motivate its conclusions and the failure to identify the factual circumstances”.
His colleague, the magistrate of Ulan-Ude lost material in relation to the driver for driving under the influence, which then led to the cancellation of the decision on bringing the driver to administrative responsibility and gave him the right to demand compensation of moral harm. In addition, the judge also committed irregularities in the conduct of statistics and has established the work of his administration, which for two years has changed 24. However, she does not deny yourself the right to regularly go on vacation, and one took just six months without approval of the guide for the care of the niece, although that had a mother.
the Judge of Butyrsky R��isuda of the capital, twice previously nazvavshayasya, lost gowns for red tape and violation of terms of consideration of cases, in 69 of which have not been formed production, and 86 cases of administrative violations were without movement, although in the information database of the court was entered inaccurate information on the cases.
In the Volgograd Deputy Chairman of the Central regional court has considered the jurisdiction he care about parole release of the convicted for serious crimes the men, who also have not served half of the punishment. Thus the judge ordered the prisoner transported to court on another case, who was in his production as a witness, though he was not.
In the Kemerovo region world judge falsified the sentence by making the change on punishment after his announcement.
the other judges were differences between the sentence issued to the parties and to the case. The differences amounted to more than 800 words and 200 words were new.
In Kozul court of Krasnoyarsk region judge, as specified in the report of the disciplinary Board of the armed forces, issued a sentence instead of “is unknown according to the form and content of the document”, which, incidentally, was made outside the deliberation room.
Another judge, not arriving at the meeting in a civil lawsuit car owner to the “Rosgosstrakh” about collecting of insurance compensation under the contract of insurance, made the decision to “retroactively” with orders to make a record of the hearing.
of special note is the early termination of powers of judges of the Kurganinskiy district court of Krasnodar territory. In April 2016, the citizens reported in the regional Department of the Ministry of interior about the noisy company in the garage. General description the patrol found several men, one of whom, refusing to produce documents, swore at police and started to attack them, starting a brawl.
he was handcuffed and brought to the office, but there’s the brawler, which, as it turned out, was a judge, a head hit in the forehead district and repeatedly kicked the Sergeant’s leg.
similarly distinguished judge of the Central regional court of Volgograd. 27 Nov 2017 she heard the last word of the accused in a criminal case, retiring to the deliberation room for sentencing, scheduled for 4 December. But the next day did not work out. But during absence it on his jeep Toyota Land Cruiser made an accident, damaging five cars. As it turned out, the judge was drunk in her blood detected was 1.1 per Mille of alcohol.
She took the claim to the General Director of JSC “Design Institute “Sproutmaster”” about collecting of the losses caused by his fault legal entities, suspending its powers, that led to loss of 6.7 million rubles In the armed forces stressed that to attribute it to error�� impossible, as the judge had “relevant experience”, considered in recent years, more than 700 civil cases.
this is recognized by the inadvertent errors of judges became the reason for the cancellation of a number of earlier decisions on early termination of powers of judges. In addition, the mantle was returned to the magistrate of the Dagestani Kizilyurt, who during a road conflict hit the man in the face.
in addition, took into account the expiration of the term of bringing him to justice, only the positive characteristics and the presence of a dependent sick wife and children.
Sergey Sergeev
